next up previous contents index
Next: 4.5.3 Comparison to Lattice Up: 4.5 An Automata Model Previous: 4.5.1 Introduction

4.5.2 Comparison to Particle Dynamics Models

The purpose of the lattice grain model is to predict the behavior of large numbers of grains (10,000 to 1,000,000) on scales much larger than a grain diameter. In this respect, it goes beyond the particle dynamics calculations of Section 9.2, which are limited to no more than grains by currently available computing resources [Cundall:79a], [Haff:87a;87b], [Walton:84a], [Werner:87a]. The particle dynamics models follow the motion of each individual grain exactly, and may be formulated in one of two ways depending upon the model adopted for particle-particle interactions.

In one formulation, the interparticle contact times are assumed to be of finite duration, and each particle may be in simultaneous contact with several others [Cundall:79a], [Haff:87a], [Walton:84a], [Werner:87a]. Each particle obeys Newton's law, F = ma, and a detailed integration of the equations of motion of each particle is performed. In this form, while useful for applications involving a much smaller number of particles than LGrM allows, PDM cannot compete with LGrM for systems involving large numbers of grains because of the complexity of PDM ``automata.''

In the second, simpler formulation, the interparticle contact times are assumed to be of infinitesimal duration, and particles undergo only binary collisions (the hard-sphere collisional models) [Haff:87b]. Hard-sphere models usually rely upon a collision-list ordering of collision events to avoid the necessity of checking all pairs of particles for overlaps at each time step. In regions of high particle number density, collisions are very frequent; and thus in problems where such high-density zones appear, hard-sphere models spend most of their time moving particles through very small distances using very small time steps. In granular flow, zones of stagnation where particles are very nearly in contact much of the time, are common, and the hard-sphere model is therefore unsuitable, at least in its simplest form, as a model of these systems. LGrM avoids these difficulties because its time-stepping is controlled, not by a collision list but by a scan frequency, which in turn is a function of the speed of the fastest particle and is independent of number density. Furthermore, although fundamentally a collisional model, LGrM can also mimic the behavior of consolidated or stagnated zones of granular material in a manner which will be described.



next up previous contents index
Next: 4.5.3 Comparison to Lattice Up: 4.5 An Automata Model Previous: 4.5.1 Introduction



Guy Robinson
Wed Mar 1 10:19:35 EST 1995